Substack keeps coming up in my conversations with founders and consultants. It usually starts with a frustration: posts that used to reach people don't seem to travel the way they once did. Then comes the question. Should we be on Substack too?
If that's on your mind, this post is for you. By the end, you'll know what Substack actually does well, what it costs you in time, how it plays with Google and your website, and a simple way to test it without betting your whole content plan on it.
Why so many people are asking about Substack right now
There isn't one reason. A few things are happening at once, and together they make an email newsletter look a lot more appealing than it did a few years ago.
Social reach is shrinking. On LinkedIn, AuthoredUp analyzed about 3 million posts from more than 30,000 profiles and found the typical post's reach fell by more than 47% in a year, from a median of 1,211 to 636. Search Engine Journal was still reporting a drop of about that size in August 2026.
Meta's platforms tell a similar story. Socialinsider's analysis of organic posts from brands with 1,000 to 1 million followers, covering January 2025 through August 2026, found that Facebook Page posts reach fewer than 2% of a page's followers on average, and Instagram reach dropped 14% year over year. In December 2025, Facebook also began testing a limit of two link posts a month for some Pages and professional profiles unless they pay for Meta Verified. It's a test, not a policy, but it points in a clear direction: social platforms want people to stay on the platform, not click away to your website.
Search is sending fewer clicks. In a Pew Research Center study of Google searches from March 2025, people clicked a regular search result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, compared with 15% when it didn't. When Google answers the question itself, fewer people make it to the website that earned the answer.
People want something they own. Every one of these platforms can change its rules overnight, and you can't take your followers with you when it does. An email list is different. Your subscribers are yours, and Substack lets you export your list whenever you want.
Feeds are filling up with AI-written posts. Pangram, an AI-detection company, analyzed about a million posts scanned by users of its browser extension and found that more than 40% of long-form LinkedIn posts were fully AI-generated. A newsletter from a person you chose to hear from is a different experience from a feed, and that's part of the appeal.
If your business runs on your ideas and your point of view, that combination hurts. Your thinking has fewer ways to find new people. Substack sits in an interesting spot: an email list you own, plus a network that can still help strangers find you.
What Substack is actually good at
Most email platforms are a mailing list with a nice editor. Substack is that plus a social network. It has its own app, a feed called Notes, and a recommendations system where writers suggest each other's newsletters to their readers.
That network is the real reason to consider it. In early 2024, Substack said its app and recommendations drove 50% of all new subscriptions on the platform and 25% of new paid subscriptions. That's the company's own number, so I'd treat it as a claim rather than an audit. Still, it points to something a standard newsletter tool or a blog can't offer: a built-in way for strangers to find you.
Substack readers are also used to paying for writing. The platform passed 5 million paid subscriptions in March 2025. Even if you never charge for your newsletter, that tells you something about the culture. People come to Substack to read, and a lot of them are willing to pay for it.
Isn't Substack filling up with AI writing too?
It's a fair question. In that same Pangram analysis, Substack had the lowest rate of AI-written long-form posts of the platforms measured, but the rate wasn't low: 21.9% of Substack posts were flagged as AI-generated or AI-assisted. (The data came from people who chose to use Pangram's extension, so it isn't a random sample.)
Substack's response has been transparency rather than bans. Since July 2026, readers can scan a post or Note to see Pangram's estimate of how much of it was AI-assisted, and writers can add a "How I make this" note explaining their process. In October 2026, Substack added a feed setting that lets readers automatically label AI-generated material. Substack hasn't said it demotes AI-written posts. In announcing the change, CEO Chris Best wrote that readers "should have a choice in the matter."
The practical takeaway: if you use AI in your writing process, be open about how. On Substack, your readers can check.
Are Substack readers really wealthier?
You'll often hear that Substack readers are more educated and have more money to spend than the audiences on other platforms. I looked into it, and it's partly supported. A Pew Research Center survey from August 2025 found that people who get news from email newsletters lean educated and higher income. Among college graduates, 35% get news this way often or sometimes, compared with 25% of people with a high school diploma or less. Among upper-income adults it's 38%, compared with 27% of lower-income adults.
That's newsletters in general, though, not Substack. I couldn't find solid demographic data on Substack readers specifically. There's a statistic going around that more than 60% of Substack visitors earn over $100,000, but I couldn't find who measured it, so I wouldn't lean on it. It's also worth knowing that in a March 2026 Verasight survey, 54% of American adults said they didn't know what Substack is. It's a big platform, but it isn't everyone.
Will your Substack articles show up on Google?
Yes, Substack content gets found in search. Semrush estimates that substack.com and its subdomains rank for about 6.1 million keywords in U.S. Google results and draw roughly 9.9 million visits a month from search (Semrush data pulled October 2026). Each post also gets an editable SEO title, search description and URL that you can set before publishing.
A few details matter, though.
- Use your own domain. Substack lets you put your publication on a custom domain or subdomain, such as newsletter.yourcompany.com, for a one-time $50 fee. That way the search credit your writing earns builds on your brand.
- New publications may start slow. Some writers report that brand-new Substacks don't get a sitemap or the built-in Google Search Console option until they've built some audience. Substack hasn't published a rule about this, so I'd treat it as a possibility rather than a certainty. For what it's worth, Substack's own 2023 data on how fast Google crawls posts was measured for publications with more than 100 subscribers.
- You can't tell Google which copy is the original. Many blog platforms let you add a canonical tag that marks a post as a copy of one published elsewhere. Substack doesn't offer that option. That matters if you want to publish the same article in two places, which brings us to the next question.
What happens if your Substack and your website compete on Google?
I wondered this myself. If both my website and my Substack rank for the same search, isn't that two spots instead of one? What's the harm?
It depends on whether they're two different pieces or the same piece twice.
Two different pieces on the same topic are good. If your Substack has an opinion essay and your website has a step-by-step guide on the same subject, both can rank. That really is two spots. One limit to know: Google usually shows no more than two results from the same site in its top results, and it generally counts subdomains as part of the main site. So two spots is about the most you'd get anyway.
The same article copied into both places usually gets you one spot. When Google finds duplicate content, it generally picks one version to show and filters out the others, and you don't get to choose which. In news publishing, republished copies on other sites often rank as well as or above the original. If your Substack copy wins, a searcher lands on your newsletter instead of next to your services and your contact page. Links and shares also get split between the two copies, so neither is as strong as one would have been.
There's no penalty for this, and it isn't dangerous. It's just wasted effort. You wrote something once and still only got one result. Writing two different pieces gets you two.
Does Substack replace your blog?
For most businesses, no. They do different jobs.
Your blog is your library. It answers the questions your buyers type into Google or ask ChatGPT, like how to choose a CRM or what a fractional CMO actually does. Those articles stay useful for years, and they sit right next to your services, so a reader who finds one is a click away from working with you.
Your Substack is your letter. It's your point of view, written for people who already chose to hear from you. It can be timely, personal and opinionated. Nobody searches for what I think about this week's AI news, but that kind of writing is often what makes someone trust you enough to reach out.
Here's a simple test. A blog title sounds like a question someone would search for. A Substack title sounds like an opinion.
One writer can feed both without doubling the work. Here's the rhythm I'd suggest:
- Write your regular essay on Substack.
- Once a month, pick the essay that answers a question people actually search for.
- Rewrite it for your blog as an evergreen guide, with a new title, a new structure, and practical steps or examples.
- Link the two to each other.
AI tools make the rewrite in step 3 much faster, though I'd still give it a careful human edit.
There's one case where Substack can stand in for a blog: when your website can't support one well. I'm thinking of sites built with AI app builders like Lovable, or custom-coded sites hosted on platforms like Vercel, where there's often no built-in blogging system and each new article can mean a code change. These tools can be great for pages but harder to blog on, and it's easy for articles to go unnoticed by search engines. (I wrote about part of this in Is Your Lovable Site Findable by ChatGPT and Claude?) If that's you, a Substack on your own subdomain, linked from your site's menu, may serve you better than forcing a blog into a tool that wasn't built for it.
Substack still needs a front door
Here's a pattern I keep noticing. Substack's network helps people find you, but it rarely does all the finding. Creators who do well on Substack usually have a reach channel up front, like a YouTube show, a podcast, LinkedIn or speaking, that points people to the Substack for the deeper material. The Substack is where readers stay. The front door is where they arrive.
For a consultant or a founder, it looks something like this:
- Reach: LinkedIn posts, webinars, talks, and blog articles that show up in search and AI answers.
- Nurture: your Substack, where people get your thinking on a regular rhythm.
- Convert: your website, with your services and an easy way to book a conversation.
Two things make the handoff work. First, give people a concrete reason to subscribe, like the full version of the idea from your talk, a checklist or a template. "Join my newsletter" on its own doesn't move many people. Second, remember what you're actually trying to grow. If you sell services, success looks like a booked call, not a paid subscription, so your Substack should point gently toward working with you.
You can also go live on Substack
Video on Substack isn't limited to recorded posts. Substack Live lets you livestream to your subscribers, and it has been open to all publishers since January 2025. If you already host LinkedIn Lives or webinars, it's worth a look.
- Your subscribers hear about it. When you go live, Substack notifies your subscribers right away. Its help center says most viewers join through a push or email notification.
- You can bring guests. In the app, you can invite up to two other Substack creators to go live with you. Guests need a Substack account. You can also stream from your computer, not just your phone.
- The recording becomes a post. When the stream ends, Substack saves the recording as a draft post you can publish. It also has tools for clipping short highlights, and Substack says clips can publish automatically to YouTube and LinkedIn.
- You decide who can watch. A stream can be open to everyone, to all your subscribers, or only to paid subscribers.
A couple of limits to know. When Substack opened live video to everyone, it required at least 10 free subscribers in the Substack app. And if you'd like to stream from a tool like Restream, that kind of outside streaming is still in beta for select creators.
For a consultant, this can be a natural fit. A monthly live Q&A or a conversation with a guest gives subscribers a reason to show up, and the recording gives you clips for LinkedIn.
The honest part: what it costs you
Substack is free to start. If you charge for your newsletter, Substack keeps 10% of that revenue, plus card processing fees. For a free newsletter, there's no fee at all. Fees have become a sore point for some writers with large paid audiences, and some have left over it, but that's less likely to matter if you're using a free newsletter to grow a service business.
The real cost is time, and the bar has gone up.
- Growth is slower than it used to be. Wes Pearce, who grew a Substack past 10,000 subscribers in about a year, says a few Notes used to bring in around 100 new subscribers overnight, and that happens less and less now. His growth didn't really take off until around month ten.
- The network rewards participation. Writers describe posting Notes daily and restacking (Substack's version of reposting) other writers in their niche. According to writers who track it, the Notes feed changed in late 2025 to show people mostly content from writers they don't follow. That helps new voices get seen, but it means you have to keep showing up.
- Video is becoming part of the picture. Beyond live video, Substack launched a TV app in January 2026 and a built-in recording studio in March. You don't have to make video, but the platform is clearly heading that way.
- Results vary a lot. For every success story, someone else tried it for three months and gained almost nothing. Many of the success stories you'll come across are also written by people who sell Substack growth courses, so I'd read them with that in mind.
Is your audience already on Substack?
Before you commit, it's worth an hour of homework to see whether the people you want to reach are already reading there.
- Search Substack for your topic. Use the search in the app or on substack.com with the terms your buyers would use, not your industry jargon.
- Look up the people your buyers already follow. Think of the authors, analysts and peers your clients mention. Are they publishing on Substack?
- Browse the category leaderboards. The app has Rising and Bestseller leaderboards by category, such as Business and Technology. They only rank publications with paid subscriptions, so they show part of the picture, not all of it.
- Check for signs of life. For the publications you find, look at how often they publish and how much conversation their posts and Notes get. A few active writers with real discussion is a better sign than a long list of quiet ones.
- Ask your audience. Add a one-line question to your next email or run a quick LinkedIn poll: "Do you read any newsletters on Substack?" Even a handful of replies tells you something.
If you find a few active writers serving the same people you serve, that's encouraging. They're also your natural starting point for recommendations and collaborations later. If you find almost nothing, you may be early, or your buyers may simply spend their reading time somewhere else.
Can you bring the email list you already have?
Yes. Substack lets you upload a CSV of your current subscribers, and there's no charge to import them or to email them. Substack makes its money from a 10% cut of paid subscriptions, so a free newsletter costs nothing to send, whatever the size of your list.
A few things to know first:
- They need to have opted in. Substack asks you to make sure everyone on your list agreed to receive emails from you. A spreadsheet of business contacts who never signed up for a newsletter doesn't qualify.
- Imports don't always go smoothly. One writer found his imports held for review for days at a time. Another saw fewer addresses come through than her export contained, and some of her imported readers received a generic invitation instead of her welcome email.
- Inviting can beat importing. Because of that, some writers email their list first, explain the move, and invite people to subscribe on Substack themselves. It's slower, but everyone who arrives chose to be there.
Who Substack is a good fit for
It's worth a serious look if:
- Your business is built on your ideas and your point of view.
- You can publish on a steady rhythm, every week or every other week.
- You can spend a few minutes most days in the Substack app, posting Notes and engaging with other writers.
- You already have a reach channel, like LinkedIn, speaking or webinars, that can send people to it.
It's probably not your next step if:
- You can't commit to writing regularly. An empty Substack doesn't help anyone.
- Your buyers find you mainly by searching for specific services. Your website and blog deserve the attention first.
- You're hoping it will replace the work of building an audience somewhere else.
If you want to try it
Here's how I'd set up a low-risk test:
- Put your Substack on your own subdomain so the search credit builds on your brand.
- Keep one email list. If your website platform also sends newsletters, choose one home for your list so subscribers don't get split between two. Substack lets you export your subscriber list whenever you want.
- Publish essays on Substack and evergreen guides on your blog. Never paste the same article into both.
- Spend a few minutes most days in Notes. Post, restack and reply.
- Point your existing channels to it, with a specific reason to subscribe.
- Give it six months. Then look at where your subscribers came from, comparing the ones who found you through Substack's network with the ones you brought in yourself. That tells you whether the network is earning its keep.
Substack isn't a replacement for your website, and it won't do your marketing for you. But if your business runs on what you think, and you're willing to show up regularly, it's one of the more promising channels to add right now, especially with LinkedIn reach shrinking.
If you're weighing this for your own business, I'd love to hear where you land. And if you'd like a second set of eyes on how Substack fits with your website and content plan, that's exactly the kind of thing we help with at Falls River Media.
Facts checked as of October 28, 2026.